Score: 10

"Perfect"

submission: Doeo!

date: May 13, 2008

I wish this had a thousand levels. I could catch doeo all damn day.

Who did the music in the first and second stage? Do those have titles? They're hopelessly stuck in my head!

Score: 10

"Greatly amusing"

submission: Bioshlock 2

date: March 12, 2008

Thanks to a anonymous tip I now know I have been referenced by another cartoon at least once!

It's unfortunate that I only get any of this because I've *heard* everything there is to know about Bioshock, never having had access to any current-gen system but the Wii. If they would only make a Wii bioshock title, like, I dunno, Big Daddy Tennis, that would be freaking awesome.

Score: 10

"Hilarious"

submission: Retarded Animal Babies 18

date: April 13, 2007

You don't see enough planaria in animation. I liked the tentacles, too. All the hallucinatory creatures, really.

Score: 10

"Can't wait for more."

submission: Clock Suckers Episode 1

date: April 12, 2007

That was really, REALLY funny. It's always nice to see someone doing real, structured comedy and storytelling.

Score: 10

"Great animation"

submission: Shoo Fly

date: April 10, 2007

SO professionally done. Barely anyone puts that kind of work into Flash, which is a shame.

Score: 9

"Monkeys!"

submission: Fiberglass Monkey

date: April 7, 2007

Really great coloring and animation, hilarious expressions, and perfectly in tune to the song.

Score: 10

"Nicely put together"

submission: When Robots Attack

date: April 7, 2007

Animating a whole cartoon like an "assembly line" is a clever idea, and some of the loops you created were great. It did start to make me a little dizzy in places, but the sheer amount of drawing you did for this is fairly impressive.

In fact, I'll be one of the few to say that this is a great bit of animation with or without music by Lemon Demon.

Score: 9

"Always amusing"

submission: The Ultimate Showdown

date: April 7, 2007

Others have said that there isn't enough animation and that it all just comes down to how good the song is, but that's not really fair. You put a lot of effort into the artwork and some of the expressions are just priceless.

Score: 9

"There's a reason everybody loves this stuff."

submission: Salad Fingers

date: April 2, 2007

I loved this cartoon long before it became an internet sensation, and even though I have an entirely different style for my first series, Salad Fingers is part of what encouraged me to try Flash for myself.

You have one of the most unique imaginations I have ever seen, and I love that you put it to animation without a care for how people might respond to it. It's real, uninhibited creativity.

Score: 10

"For what it is, it's great!"

submission: Salad Fingers Lemon Tree

date: April 2, 2007

Sure, it's someone else's artwork and someone else's music, but unlike so many other, crappier "music videos" on NG, you've clearly put a great deal of thought into the synergy between the music and the clips, and you did an expert job of that.